Established-1914
| Friday, 1 December 2006 | THE MYANMAR TIMES |
Senior General Than Shwe congratulates Mexican President
Nay Pyi Taw, 1 Dec-Senior General Than Shwe, Chairman of
the State Peace and Development Council of the Union of Myanmar, has sent a
message of congratulations to His Excellency Mr Felipa Calderon Hinojosa,
President-elect of the United Mexican States, on the occasion of his assumption
of duty as the President of the United Mexican States.
![]()
Vice-Senior General Maung Aye receives new Military Attaché of
Lao PDR

Nay Pyi Taw, 30 Nov -Vice-Chairman of the State Peace and
Development Council of the Union of Myanmar Deputy Commander-in-Chief of Defence
Services Commander-in-Chief (Army) Vice-Senior General Maung Aye received new
Military Attaché Colonel Khamsy Vongkhamsao of the Lao People's Democratic
Republic to the Union of Myanmar at Bayintnaung Yeiktha, here, at 11 am today.
Also present at the call were Commander-in-Chief (Navy)
Vice-Admiral Soe Thein, Commander-in-Chief (Air) Lt-Gen Myat Hein, Military
Affairs Security Chief Maj-Gen Ye Myint and Deputy Military Attaché Capt
Xayasone Keonhothi of the Lao PDR.
![]()
Vice-Senior General Maung Aye receives Indonesian Military Attachés

Nay Pyi Taw, 30 Nov -Vice-Chairman of the State Peace and
Development Council of the Union of Myanmar Deputy Commander-in-Chief of Defence
Services Commander-in-Chief (Army) Vice-Senior General Maung Aye received
Defence and Military Attaché Colonel Yayat Hidayat of the Republic of Indonesia
who had completed his tour of duty and his successor Colonel Dedi Priatna
Ariestadi at Bayintnaung Yeiktha, here, at 11.30 am today.
Also present at the call were Commander-in-Chief (Navy)
Vice-Admiral Soe Thein, Commander-in-Chief (Air) Lt-Gen Myat Hein and Military
Affairs Security Chief Maj-Gen Ye Myint.
![]()
Independent Representatives-elect submit proposals on chapters
Election, Political Parties and Provisions on State of Emergency to Plenary
Session of National Convention

Yangon, 30 Nov -Independent Representatives-elect of the
Delegate Group of Representatives-elect submitted proposals on the detailed
basic principles that should be adopted for the chapters ?Election?, ?Political
Parties? and ?Provisions on State of Emergency? to be included in drafting the
State Constitution at the Plenary Session of the National Convention which
continued at Pyidaungsu Hall of Nyaunghnapin Camp in Hmawby Township, Yangon
Division, at 9 am today.
Present on the occasion were Chairman of the National
Convention Convening Commission Secretary-1 of the State Peace and Development
Council Lt-Gen Thein Sein and Commission members, Chairman of the National
Convention Convening Work Committee Chief Justice U Aung Toe and Work Committee
members, Chairman of the National Convention Convening Management Committee
Auditor-General Maj-Gen Lun Maung and Management Committee members, chairmen and
officials of subcommittees, delegates of political parties of National Unity
Party, Union Pa-O National Organization, Shan State Kokang Democratic Party, Mro
(or) Khami National Solidarity Organization, Lahu National Development Party,
Union Kayin League, Kokang Democracy and Unity Party and Wa National Development
Party, representatives-elect of National Unity Party and Mro (or) Khami National
Solidarity Organization, independent representatives, delegates of national
races from Kachin, Kayah, Kayin, Chin, Mon, Rakhine, Shan (South), Shan (North)
and Shan (East) States, Sagaing, Taninthayi, Bago, Magway, Mandalay, Yangon and
Ayeyawady Divisions, delegates of peasants from Kachin, Kayah, Kayin, Chin, Mon,
Rakhine, Shan (South), Shan (North) and Shan (East) States, Sagaing, Taninthayi,
Bago, Magway, Mandalay, Yangon and Ayeyawady Divisions, delegates of
intellectuals and intelligentsia, delegates of workers from Kachin, Kayah,
Kayin, Chin, Mon, Rakhine, Shan (South), Shan (North) and Shan (East) States,
Sagaing, Taninthayi, Bago, Magway, Mandalay, Yangon and Ayeyawady Divisions,
delegates of State Service Personnel from the State Peace and Development
Council Office, the President Office, the Pyithu Hluttaw Office, the Government
Office, the Supreme Court, the Attorney-General's Office, the Auditor-General's
Office, the Multi-party Democracy General Election Commission Office, the Civil
Service Selection and Training Board, the Yangon City Development Committee, the
Mandalay City Development Committee and ministries, other invited delegates,
delegates from Shan State (North) Special Region-1, Shan State (North) Special
Region-2, Shan State (North) Special Region-3, Shan State (East) Special
Region-4, Shan State (North) Special Region-5, Shan State (South) Special
Region-6, Kachin State Special Region-1, Kachin State Special Region-2, Kayah
State Special Region-1, Kayah State Special Region-2, Kayah State Special
Region-3, Kayinni National Democratic Party (KNDP) (Dragon) Group, Kayinni
National Progressive Party (KNPP) (Hoya), Kayinni National Unity and Solidarity
Organization (Ka Ma Sa Nya), Democratic Kayin Buddhist Organization (DKBA) and
Haungthayaw Special Region Group, Nyeinchanyay Myothit Group from Hpa-an
Township of Kayin State, Burma Communist Party (Rakhine State Group), Arakan
Army (AA), Homein Region Development and Welfare Group, Shwepyiaye (MTA), Manpan
People's Militia Group, Mon Peace Group (Chaungchi Region) and Mon Nai Seik Chan
Group that had returned to the legal fold.
Before the Plenary Session of the National Convention,
Chairman of the NCCC Secretary-1 Lt-Gen Thein Sein and Commission members,
Chairman of the NCCWC Chief Justice U Aung Toe and Work Committee members,
Chairman of the NCCMC Auditor-General Maj-Gen Lun Maung and Management Committee
members, chairmen and officials of the subcommittees, delegates of political
parties, representatives-elect, delegates of the National Races, Peasants,
Workers, Intellectuals and Intelligentsia, State Service Personnel, and Other
Invited Persons, signed attendance books at Pyidaungsu Hall and the recreation
hall.
U Maung Hla (a) U Hla Myint of Delegate Group of National
Races presided over the Plenary Session of National Convention together with,
Member of NCCWC U Myo Thant (Maung Hsu Shin), U Saw Philip (a) U Philip Sam of
Delegate Group of Political Parties, U Maung Gyi of Delegate Group of
Representatives-elect, U Kan Nyunt of Delegate Group of Peasants, U Kyaw Win Tun
of Delegate Group of Workers, Dr Maung Maung Wint of Delegate Group of
Intellectuals and Intelligentsia, U Tin Kha of Delegate Group of State Service
Personnel and Dr Manan Tu Ja of Delegate Group of Other Invited Persons.
Director (Meeting) U Than Aung of NCCWC Office acted as
Master of Ceremonies and Deputy Director U Aung Kyi as co-MC.
The MC declared the start of meeting as 1,066 out of 1,080
delegates were in attendance, accounting for 98.7 per cent, and the plenary
session commenced with the permission of the meeting chairman.
Proposals on the detailed basic principles that should be
adopted for the chapters ?Election?, ?Political Parties? and ?Provisions on
State of Emergency? to be included in drafting the State Constitution made by
Independent Representatives-elect of Delegate Group of Independent
Representatives-elect U Tin Win of Ayeyawady Division Kyaiklat Township
Constituency-2, U Thein Kyi of Magway Division Taungdwingyi Township
Constituency-1, U Hla Soe of Magway Division Minbu Township Constituency-2, U
Mya Hlaing of Yangon Division Twantay Township Constituency-2, U Kyi Win of
Mingaladon Township Constituency-1 and U Tin Tun Maung of Mingaladon Township
Constituency-2 were presented to the Plenary Session. First, Independent
Representative-elect U Kyi Win of Mingaladon Township Constituency-1 presented
proposals on the Chapter ?Election? and U Tin Tun Maung of Mingaladon Township
Constituency-2 on the Chapter ?Political Parties? and the Plenary Session took a
break at 10.05 am.
(The presentation will be reported.)
When the Plenary Session resumed at 10.25 am, Independent
Representatives-elect U Tin Win of Ayeyawady Division Kyaiklat Township
Constituency-2, U Hla Soe of Magway Division Minbu Township Constituency-2 and U
Thein Kyi of Magway Division Taungdwingyi Township Constituency-1 presented
proposals on the detailed basic principles that should be adopted for the
chapters ?Election?, ?Political Parties? and ?Provisions on State of Emergency?
to be included in drafting the State Constitution.
(The presentation will be reported.)
The Plenary Session went into recess at 11.25 am.
The Plenary Session of the National Convention continues
tomorrow.
![]()
Allegations contrary to present endeavours exerted by Government
with goodwill for prosperity of Myanmar
Nay Pyi Taw, 29 Nov-The following is the clarification made
by Director-General of Myanmar Police Force Brig-Gen Khin Yi on situation in
prisons in Myanmar at the press conference on undertakings in education, health
and social sectors of the State here yesterday.
Whilst clarifying the unfounded allegations towards
Myanmar, I would further like to report a summary of the situation in our
prisons that have been wrongly accused in the news media.
Myanmar took a considerable length of time to uphold the
Union as a united entity, forge national solidarity, work towards prevalence of
law and order with peaceful and secure living condition and at the same time,
managed to cultivate the basic prerequisite of building trust between ethnic
nationals and have placed emphasis on the development of the country by laying
down programs incomparable to any undertakings in past eras.
This scenario for peaceful development of a new country is
something that the internal and external destructive elements, together with
opposition groups should welcome warmly. Instead, they are now stirring the
tranquillity of our country with an aim to totally destroy Myanmar by attacking
from all possible fronts. Local stooges are particularly active in broadcasting
propaganda and fabricated information liberally that can generate suspicion and
insolence against the Government by the people. This is done in collusion with
external mass media organizations, TV and radio stations and through Internet.
Disregarding the prescribed ethics for news media, codes of conduct and accepted
norms, they are deliberately inflating the wrong and unfounded information to
create misunderstanding among the people. I will elaborate on the situation in
our prisons, citing actual happenings, which is one of the many fabricated tales
the destructive elements have created through the media, for all of us to
realize and understand.
From overabundant amorphous tell tales on prisons, I would
like to highlight the propagations coming from Assistance Association for
Political Prisoners (AAPP) and some of the external broadcasting stations:
- DVB station broadcast on 23 June 2006 on a dysentery
outbreak in Insein prison that is worrisome for prisoners;
- DVB station broadcast on 29 June 2006 on Government
stopping food supplies to prisoners and the need for prison staff members to
find its own ways to feed them, the absence of medical doctor in prisons
creating health problems for long term prisoners and the development of gastric
ulcers among prisoners from low quality rice they were fed;
- DVB station broadcast on 1 August 2006 on the absence of
health care within prisons with prisoners having to depend on unsafe water and
food with no nutritional values;
- Myitzima station broadcast on 15 August 2006 on prisoners
suffering from malaria, diarrhoea and malnutrition from hard labor in Buthidaung
prison in Rakhine State;
- DVB station broadcast on 22 August 2006 on prisoners
having to sleep on concrete floors causing hypertension and strokes without
proper medical care in Toungoo prison;
- DVB broadcast on 4 September 2006 on the absence of
proper medical care in prisons and refusal to refer to outside specialists and
hospitals;
- DVB broadcast on 6 November 2006 quoting the declaration
of Assistance Association for Political Prisoners (AAPP) that state that the
prisoners are not receiving their fully receiving their share of food, living
conditions, medical care, that prison authorities are reluctant to provide
protection to prisoners and that there are no medical doctors in most prisons
and ;
- Myitzima station broadcast on 8 November 2006 on severe
beatings of prisoners on arrival at Thayawady and Thayet prisons, finding faults
to put into solitary confinement, to beat up, to bar from bathing and to give
punishments, torturing physically and mentally and, finding fault and punishing
for unwrapping cheroot butts to read are the allegations that exist.
There was even an open letter sent to the Secretary General
of the United Nations on 15 November 2006 by AAPP requesting to take action
against the increasing death tolls due to sub standard medical facilities within
prisons.
If we are to examine the allegations I have just reported,
we will find that most of them are premised on the absence of medical care, poor
quality food, illegal punishments and uncaring attitudes towards prisoners. All
these allegations are negating the reality and would like to take this
opportunity to clarify the actual situation of our prisons to members of the
press and to distinguished guests present here.
Our Head of State, when visiting No (2) new life
agriculture camp under the Prisons Department on 22 January 1999, laid down the
following directives for a change in the management system of Prisons
Department:
- attempts should be made to turn prisoners into productive
people once they are released, to be able to support the country in one way or
another, to strive towards increasing productivity, to try and enhance their
status from lowly prisoners to good and useful people, to establish
rehabilitation centres and to enable to dismiss prisoners mentality;
- as labour contributors, to provide newspapers, journals,
TVs and radios so that they will constantly be in touch with the outside world;
- for those labourers who are not accompanied by their
families, leaves should be granted for them to go and meet their families during
slack seasons with warrants and some travelling allowance provided so that they
will not breed evil thoughts from long separations from their spouses and
families and;
- the new life agriculture production camp should join
hands with neighbouring villages, teach them cultivation methods and to extend
help and assistance to poor and elderly people. Distinguished guests will
understand that such directives stems from compassion and goodwill towards the
prisoners.
In line with the directives laid down by the Head of State,
the Prisons Department under the Ministry of Home Affairs is making resolute
efforts, through multi dimensional approach, towards a change in the religious,
health, social, education, welfare, food consumption and living environment of
the prisoners so that they will become productive people once released from
prisons. These efforts have resulted in noticeable changes between prisons in
the past and the present ones. I would like to highlight some of the changes
made through the process. In the religious environment:
- all the prisoners enjoy freedom of religion and can
worship any religion of their choice;
- whether they are Buddhist, Islam or other faith
believers, arrangements are being made for them to go on Sabbath if they wish;
- for prisons' labour camps that do not have Buddha
statues, the Director-General or the Deputy Director-General, during their tours
to these camps will carry a Buddha statue for Buddhist prisoners and have it
enshrined, together with prisoners for them to earn good deeds;
- morning and evening praying sessions are organized daily
for Buddhist prisoners as part of an effort to ease their state of mind;
- meditation sessions are also organized occasionally and
every fortnight, monks are brought to the prisoners' living quarters in turn to
preach, inscriptions of Buddha teachings are hung on the walls of every sleeping
quarters, prayer recital competitions are held between different quarters and
arrangements are made for prisoners, both males and females, to participate in
religious events like Waso robe offerings, Kathina robe offerings and to other
good deeds like contributing to monastery constructions, listening to preaches,
etc.
If we look into the health care facilities that are being
provided to prisoners, you will see that:
- prisoners of both sexes are urged to take morning
exercise every day for 30 minutes as soon as their living quarters are opened;
- on Independence Day every year, sport competitions are
held within the prison compound such as hiking around the prison as well as
volley ball and table tennis matches;
- medication for prisons and labour camps are issued free
of charge on a biannual basis from the medical depot of the Department of Health
and the need for additional medicines and hospital equipment are supplement form
the Government budget. From officially published records, we can see that the
Government had supplemented a total of 2,035,010 kyats for 2004-05 fiscal year
and 2,470,887 kyats for 2005-06 fiscal year. Likewise, the Ministry of Home
Affairs supplemented a total of 6,598,870 kyats for 2004-05 fiscal year and
9,843,964 kyats for 2005-06 fiscal year from funds accumulated either from the
fees generated by prisoners working in production camps or from their welfare
funds.
- for almost every prisons with hospitals, doctors and
nurses are especially assigned and for smaller prisons and labour camps without
hospitals, outside township medical officers visited these places every week
with health assistants and medical orderlies providing additional medical care
and medical records are filed systematically;
- for cases that are difficult to manage at smaller prisons
and labour camps, patients are referred to respective general hospitals or to
specialists and occasional, even let them treated through cost sharing basis
and;
- from daily records kept by prison authorities, we learn
that sleeping quarters are regularly inspected by the authorities to ensure
proper lighting and ventilation and insecticides are sprayed on a regular basis
to keep away mosquitoes, flies, ticks and mites. This verifies that the
authorities have not neglected the health and hygiene of both male and female
prisoners.
- We find that the labour camp authorities see to it that
the visiting family members have assess to food and sleeping facilities, that
responsible officials and members of NGOs visit prisoners to provide required
counselling and educational information, that round discussion sessions are held
for prisoners to share their personal experiences with their peers so that they
have no regrets and that plans are in place for prisoners to enable them to
tread their life with dignity in future as reformed persons.
At the same time education and trainings are provided to
foreigners to enable them to lead a honest life and make a decent living once
they are released from prison setting which include:
- as part of vocational programs, training sessions on
weaving, cane crafts, auto and machine mechanics, knitting, painting, sculpture,
sewing, photo mechnics, foot wear manufacturing, furniture, agriculture and
livestock breeding are held for prisoners. In Insein prison, worksites outside
the prison settings are established to engage prisoners in agriculture,
livestock breeding and rock excavation works and for young prisoners who are
involved in establishing prisoners' funds, vocational as well as academic
trainings are provided. To cite an example, in the academic year 2005-06, 35
young prisoners from Central Insein Prison were provided with school education
starting from kindergarten to fourth standard and passed the final exams with
first, second and third positions.
- during 2006-07 academic year 170 prisoners, both males
and females, were provided with school education from kindergarten to tenth
standard;
- arrangements are made to enable prisoner to read
newspapers, journals and magazines and to watch and listen to radio and TV so
that they will not loose track of the developments within and outside the
country during their punishment in prisons;
- laws prescribed for prisons allow mothers to keep their
infants together in prisons up till four years of age but allowance is made for
infants to remain up till six years of age is circumstances warrant;
- for children accompanying their mothers into prisons,
nursery schools are opened for them to learn poetry and lessons;
- a rehabilitation centre (Shwe Pyi Thar) for drug addicted
prisoners was opened on 6 January 1999 and a total of 756 addicts have been sent
there during their prison terms for treatment and rehabilitation;
- care for women centre was opened in Twantay on 5 October
2002 and a total of 938 imprisoned female HIV/AIDS patients and commercial sex
workers were sent with systematic measures in place to ensure that HIV is not
transmitted further through psychological and physical treatment and
rehabilitation programs;
- a similar centre for women was also established in
Mandalay on 5 February 2005 and a total of 124 HIV infected prisoners were sent
for rehabilitation.
I would now like to explain the activities undertaken for
the welfare of the prisoners:
- Myanmar people are inherently good-natured and most
enthusiastic donors. Even though the prisoners are undergoing punishment for
breaking one of the prevailing laws at one point of time, they are not viewed
negatively by prison staff members and are assisting them in every possible
ways, including provision of food and amenities together with NGOs who are
donating goods with zest and enthusiasm;
- enhanced health consciousness in Insein Prison led to the
installation of fly proof latrines in all sleeping quarters and plans are being
made to install likewise in other prisons;
- as part of modernizing prison visiting rooms, walls are
now paved with tiles and fans are installed and for outside living rooms, floors
are laid with tiles with modern furniture furnished to upgrade the mental
wellbeing of the prisoners;
- at the new life agriculture production camp, prisoners
are given leave to return to their families after one year or residence and this
is based on the individual prisoner's character, integrity, determination to
work and adherence to prisons' rules and regulation. From the records of Prisons
Department, we learnt that a total of 775 prisoners were granted home leave
since 1999.
The Prisons Department is obliging and catering to the food
requirements of prisoners and my observations on this aspect are:
- with the arrangement of prisons and camps, freshly cooked
meals are served everyday to prisoners for their health with meat, fish and
special vegetable dishes served at least once a week from farm produce for
prisoners;
- reverse osmosis system water purifying plants worth 43
million kyats is being installed at Insien prison with funds donated from
outside sources and the prisoners are getting 3 litres of purified water for
their daily consumption. Another water purifying plant worth 1.5 million kyats
had also been installed within the female quarter of Lashio prison from funds
generated through fund raising activities spearheaded by the Commander of North
East Command. Another plant donated for Thayawady prison is now in the process
of constructing the building to house the plant and an accompanying tank which
should become operational soon.
- Donations for installing water purifying plants at
Mandalay, Myingyan, Mawlamyine, Myaungmya, Buthidaung, Loikaw and Taunggyi
prisons are in receipt now and installation process will commence soon;
- Although there are unfounded allegations on prisoners
having to sleep on concrete floors, we find that all prison sleeping quarters
are inlaid with wooden coverings and for prisons at cooler regions, adequate
blankets are being issued to prisoners and facilities with ample water supplies
exist for bathing and washing. And prisoners are provided with soap for bathing
and washing on a weekly basis.
In reality, as I have explained earlier, the cost of
maintaining the prisons under the Prisons Department and the cost of providing
adequate food and supplies to prisoners are borne through the allocated
Government budget with the Ministry of Home Affairs, under the arrangement of
Prisons Department, supplementing through the funds generated by the prisoners
themselves through their labour. In addition, we have witnessed local
non-governmental organizations such as Myanmar Women's Affairs Federation,
Myanmar Maternal and Child Welfare Association, Myanmar Red Cross Society and
Fire Brigades together with outside donors joining hands, as part of our
inherent good nature and enthusiasm, contacting the authorities to visit prisons
and camps to extending help and assistance enthusiastically in every possible
way they can.
Through these help and assistance, prisoners today are
enjoying privileges such as basic nutritional diet, adequate health care, rest
and recreation during free time, books and literature to read, engage in
physical fitness activities and keeping in close contact with their family
members.
Both the humanitarian organization and individuals who have
lend assistance to prisoners and detainees, like typical Myanmar nationals, are
most gratified to be able to contribute to this noble exercise. The individual,
who financed the installation of water purifying plant at Insein Prison, also
financed the installation of a similar plant at Thayawady prison out of pure
compassion. Here, I would like to emphasize the fact that a similar donor, with
an aim to purify the lives of people under imprisonment, donated a water
purifying plant for the female quarter of Lashio is nothing but a gesture of the
inborn nature of Myanmar people not to discriminate its own kind.
There are a total of 42 prisons and 91 labour camps under
the management of the Prisons Department, Ministry of Home Affairs out of which
all 42 prisons and 7 labour camps are being visited by representatives from
humanitarian organizations in Myanmar between October 2005 and November 2006 and
met with prisoners and detainees to extend necessary assistance and donate goods
of their needs. Their total donations in terms of food stuff, basic necessities,
medicines, novels, journals and magazines amounted to more than 75 million kyats
(755520787) and the lists are being displayed on board for your review.
As I have explained earlier, external news media,
broadcasting stations and destructive elements including AAPP are alleging that:
- Myanmar prisons are not providing nutritional food to
prisoners, there are outbreaks of contiguous diseases in the prisons and safe
and adequate drinking water is not available therein;
- there are not enough prison doctors;
- prisoners have to sleep on concrete floors and;
- inhuman torture and treatment exist in prisons.
- no opportunities exist to read and study in prisons which
are all generalized. As I have explained earlier, members of press and
distinguished guests will be in a position to gauge whether these allegations
actually reflect the prevailing reality. Specific directives laid down by the
Government coupled with close scrutiny at all levels by responsible persons have
now changed the present day prison management scenarios in Myanmar.
In other words, the goodwill and concerted efforts of the
Government, responsible officials, individual donors and NGOs have led the
relationships between prisoners and staff members to evolved into a family like
structure where all inherent rights in the fields of health care, social needs,
freedom to worship, food requirements, living conditions and welfare facilities
call all be enjoyed within the prescribed legal framework. This clearly
demonstrates that the unfounded allegations disseminated through external media
sources are fabrications directed at discrediting the solidarity of our country.
The Prisons Department, in line with the motto of the
Ministry of Home Affairs Eradicate colonial characteristic, safeguard the
interest of the people and the State? is an institute that is extending deserved
rights to prisoners in accordance with laid down orders, directives and
prescribed jail manuals that are in conformity with prevailing time and
circumstances. We have officially announced in various local newspapers that any
evidence on individuals who have interacted harshly, suppressed rudely and
engaged in acts of torture against prisoners, in defiance to the above mentioned
policy, can be reported to responsible authorities including the Ministry of
Home Affairs. Actually, this is a formal interpretation of the policy laid down
by our Head of State that clearly defines that nobody is above the law. In other
words, it means that this is part of the process to establish an orderly
democratic system where the prevalence of clean governance is a prerequisite.
All I can say at this juncture is that the shameless allegations put forward by
internal and external destructive elements together with some international news
media runs contrary to the present schemes the Government had been exerting with
goodwill for future prosperity of Myanmar.
![]()
Myanmar can never condone human trafficking and will continue to
cooperate with neighbours, other humanitarian organizations, in combating the
threat
Nay Pyi Taw, 30 Nov-The following is the clarification on
anti-human trafficking made by Director General Brig-Gen Khin Yi of Myanmar
Police Force at the press conference on undertakings carried out in the
education, health and social affairs sectors of the State, here, yesterday.
I would like to further clarify, citing actual incidence,
to the prevailing allegations against Myanmar's efforts in combating human
trafficking together with actual facts and figures.
In the present days, the problem of human trafficking has
become widespread all around the world. Internationally, this problem is
recognized as ?slavery? that have vanished 200 years ago and re-emerged in a
form of modern day slavery in the 1990s. Researchers viewed the disintegration
of the Soviet Union and the rapid advancement of information technology to be
the major factors that led to re-emergence of modern day slavery commonly known
as human trafficking. The worldwide spared of this problem emanated particularly
from increased trafficking of females from Eastern European to Western European
countries.
Human trafficking is as a lucrative business that yield
high returns from low investments and this invite gluttonous Organized Criminal
Groups to commit crimes regardless of territorial borders. Nowadays, human
trafficking has become part of defiant issue like terrorism and drug trafficking
that is threatening the entire humankind. Accordingly, in the year 2000, the UN
Convention against Transnational Organized Crimes and a Protocol to Prevent,
Suppress and Punish Trafficking in Persons was drafted and adopted unanimously
with a pledge for international cooperation in combating the threat.
Human trafficking is a clandestine crime and therefore,
hard to find out the exact people who have been trafficked. It is however
estimated that, more than 27 million people have become victims worldwide with
an additional of one to two million annually from which there is a profit of
more than 1.5 trillion US dollars every year from this trade.
From observations we know that: in Asia, this
issue is prevalent in Bangladesh, Cambodia, China, India,
Laos, Myanmar, Nepal, Pakistan, Philippines, Thailand and Vietnam; people from
this region are mostly trafficked to Britain, Japan and the United States; at
least three hundred thousand women and children from Mekong Sub-Region including
Myanmar are being trafficked annually and; South East Asia is ranked amongst
regions with high human trafficking incidence with a share of 54% of the whole
of Asia.
As we all know, the world began to take notice of the human
trafficking problem in 1990s and this evolved into a major issue around the year
2000. Myanmar became aware of the problem since then and after the World Women's
Conference held in Beijing in 1995, we started to initiate measures to address
this issue that impinges on the personnel well being of women. As part of the
process, the Myanmar National Committee for Women's Affairs chaired by the
Minister for Social Welfare, Relief and Resettlement was formed on 3 July 1995
and through its newly established working committees, measures were taken, as a
priority, to protect women and children from being trafficked. The
establishments of Myanmar National Working Committee for Women's Affairs chaired
by the Deputy Minister for Social Welfare, Relief and Resettlement and the
Working Committee for Prevention of Trafficking in Persons chaired by the Deputy
Minister for Home Affairs and followed on 7 October 1996 and 17 July 2002
respectively.
In this connection, I would like to present that Myanmar
adopted the National Plan of Action in 1997 to suppress human trafficking and
consist of measures to prevent, prosecute, protect, rehabilitate and
reintegrate. The plan is based on Multi-Sectoral Approach in line with
internationally recognized strategy and is being implemented since.
Moreover, the National Task Force was also formed in 1997
with members representing both governmental and non-governmental agencies and is
holding mass media campaigns through educational sessions, pamphlets and video
plays. They are being presented not only through Myanmar Radio and Television
stations but committees at various levels assisted in presenting them through
video parlours based in wards and villages. Ten video plays depicting true
trafficking incidences are being produced in both Myanmar and Shan dialects and
are being staged all through the Shan States including border areas.
As a joint endeavour between Myanmar National Committee for
Women's Affairs and UN Inter Agency Project on Human Trafficking in the Greater
Mekong Sub Region (UNIAP), a Mobile Training Team was formed in the year 2000
with representatives from various Government Departments and has trained 500
officials from State and Divisional level Government Departments that deal with
human trafficking problem. As one of the measures to deter women from making a
living across border, micro credit loan is being introduced to start a local
vocational business. Financial assistance is being provided to poor children to
further their education.
In addition, 2001 a Central Supervision Committee led by
the Director General of Myanmar Police Force is being formed with subsequent
sub-committees at state, district, township and village levels to prevent people
from leaving the country illegally which serves as a main cause for trafficking
people. Since its formation on 23 September 2001, the committee was able to
persuade 868,995 persons from illegal migration and took action against 1,638
brokers.
The Government of Myanmar opened a receiving centre in
Myawady on 18 February 2002 to receive, without taking action, and extend
necessary assistance to those who left the country illegally and returned home
after getting into trouble outside. From the date the camp opened on 18 February
up to 30 October 2006, it received 20,883 returnees and sent them back to their
families. A total of 303 trafficked victims who were repatriated from foreign
countries were received and returned to their respective parents or guardians.
With a resolve to suppress human trafficking, Myanmar held
its First ever National Seminar on Human Trafficking in May 2003 in Yangon
successfully. The Ministers for Home Affairs and Social Welfare, Relief and
Resettlement together with Myanmar National Committee for Women's Affairs,
UNIAP, UNICEF and Save the Children (UK) coordinated to hold the Seminar that
served as a milestone in a joint effort between Myanmar, UN Agencies and INGOs
in combating human trafficking. Future working plans were adopted by the seminar
which is being currently implemented.
In Myanmar 53% of its total population are women and our
traditional norms and culture placed them on an equal footing with men. In order
to undertake comprehensive approaches to the overall development and personal
safety of women, Myanmar Women's Affairs Federation (MWAF) was formed on 20
December 2003 and since then, have been working towards preventing, suppressing
and assisting women and children from being trafficked.
As part of preventive measures, information on the nature
and modes of human trafficking are being distributed widely and, suppressive
measures include training, discussions and educational sessions together with
teams to provide required counselling. Assistance activities include providing
advice to returnees, organizing rehabilitation programs, caring for their health
and sending the returnees back to their families in close cooperation with other
humanitarian organizations and INGOs.
In order to emphasize matters relating to human
trafficking, the Department against Transnational Crime (DTC) of Myanmar Police
Force, in close cooperation with ARCPPT Project implemented under the agreement
signed between the Governments of Australia and Myanmar and formed a 40-member
strong Anti Trafficking Unit in 2004 with police officials. Similarly, members
of task forces trained by internationally recognized experts are assigned to
nine major and border towns like Muse, Tachilek, Myawady, Mawlamyaing,
Kawthoung, Bhamo, Kalay, Mandalay and Yangon to suppress human trafficking.
Myanmar Police Force managed to take action against 786
cases involving 1,638 offenders ? 887 males and 751 females ? during the period
17 July 2002 to 30 October 2006. At the end of the trial of 308 cases, life
sentences were imposed on 3 offenders, above 10 years imprisonment for 101
offenders, under 5 years for 350 offenders, below 5 years for the remaining 158
out of the total 612 offenders. A total of 3,875 victims ? 1,978 males and 1,887
females ? were rescued from the hands of traffickers and were returned to their
respective families. Considering this, you all can see how the government is
implementing in dealing with anti-trafficking in persons.
As Myanmar do not have specific laws to take action against
human trafficking, we have initiated, since January 2004, to develop drafting
process that will conform to the international conventions and later in
September 2004, international legal experts were invited to review the first
draft. Taking into consideration of the advice given by international legal
experts as well as the prevailing situation in Myanmar, the Anti-Trafficking in
Persons Law was promulgated on 13 September 2005. Since then, action was taken
against 36 cases and 44 offenders were put on trial in line with the law which
prescribed imprisonment for life (to serve in the prison until death) to guilty
traffickers. There are also provisions that allow confiscation of trafficker's
properties which makes the law a very powerful tool for suppressing human
trafficking.
To effectively implement the provisions contained in the
Anti-Trafficking in Person Law, the Central Body for Suppression of Trafficking
in Persons was formed on 11 February 2006. The Working Group on Prevention of
Trafficking in Persons and Protection of Trafficked Victims, the Working Group
on Legal Framework and Prosecuting Measures and the Working Group on
Repatriation, Reintegration and Rehabilitation of Trafficked Victims were also
formed on 27 February 2006. Subsequent bodies for suppression of Trafficking in
Persons at State and Division, District and Township levels have already been
formed and anti-trafficking projects are now being implemented.
Myanmar had not only tackled this problem from all aspects
within the country but is also placing emphasis on international cooperation by
becoming a party to the following international conventions affiliated with
human trafficking:
(1) the Convention on the Rights of the Child,
(2) the Convention on Elimination of all Forms of
Discrimination Against Women,
(3) the Forced Labour Convention No 29,
(4) the Convention Against Transnational Organized Crime,
(5) the Protocol to Prevent, Suppress and Punish
Trafficking in Persons, especially Women and Children,
(6) the Protocol to Combat Smuggling of Migrants in Land,
Sea and Air,
(7) the Convention Against Corruption and;
(8) Treaty on Mutual Legal Assistance in Criminal Matters
and have been cooperating closely with members of ASEAN.
Myanmar together with Cambodia, Laos and Thailand, signed a
Memorandum of Understanding on 22 December to implement the ARCPPT Project.
These project activities include training members of Myanmar Police Force, and
accordingly 104 police officials have been trained and visited major towns
within States and Divisions with high incidences of trafficking to impart
knowledge and information. This is being undertaken in 9 States and Divisions
for 14 times. The activities also include strengthening of Criminal Justice
Systems by providing sound technical assistance and enhancing cooperation among
countries where the project is being implemented.
Additionally, to initiate effective measures in combating
human trafficking in the Mekong Sub-Region, Myanmar hosted the Coordinated
Mekong Ministerial Initiative against Trafficking (COMMIT) meeting in October
2004 with the participation of all six countries that form Mekong Sub-Region
namely Cambodia, China, Laos, Myanmar, Thailand and Vietnam where a Memorandum
of Understanding on cooperation in combating human trafficking was successfully
signed. In accordance with COMMIT MoU, a plan of action was developed and is now
being implemented in all member countries. Representatives from six member
countries occasionally meet in a form of meetings, seminars and workshops to
discuss matters relating to exchange of information and experiences and to
extend reciprocal assistance as part of cooperation and action plan implementing
process.
On 15 January 2005, a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) was
also signed between Myanmar and China who shared common borders, to combat
transnational crimes and to maintain restore peace along the borders of the two
countries. Singing another MoU between the two counties to combat human
trafficking is another provision prescribed in the signed MoU and to realize
this provision, the first meeting of senior officials from two countries was
held in November 2005 in Bagan, Myanmar followed by a second meeting in November
2006 in Kunming, China.
In addition, as we are members of both ASEAN and BIMSTEC,
we would like you all to know that the activities laid down by these
organizations are also been implemented.
As I have stated earlier, Myanmar had earnestly striven to
suppress human trafficking where the cooperation of our nationals have played an
important role in gaining practical achievements. From these achievements, I
would like to share some outstanding incidences.
On 20 July 2006, learning that two Myanmar girls were held
in custody in a hotel room of a border town of a neighbouring country from a
dutiful citizen, members of Muse district police force and special anti-human
trafficking unit, with the aide of police from the neighbouring country, rescued
the two trafficked Myanmar girls and arrested the two traffickers ? Kyaw Myint
and Soe Soe Mar? who held the girls in custody. They were taken action by Muse
Police station in accordance with the Anti-Trafficking in Persons Law.
From investigations, we learnt that both Kyaw Myint and Soe
Soe Mar were active traffickers that lured local girls to be sold across the
border. From this connection, we were able to expose a total of 64
traffickers-51 locals and 13 foreigners.
From the gang leader Kyaw Myint himself, we learnt that he
had sold off more than 90 girls to a neighbouring country and with the
cooperation of the police force from that country, we were able to arrest
another 34 persons linked to the case and we are still in process of exposing
additional 30 offenders.
From trafficker Kyaw Myint, we have confiscated a mobile
phone, a million kyats deposited at Muse Yoma Bank by his wife, a raw jade
weighing 24.8 kilos and another one weighing 11 kilos, from another trafficker
Fatty @ Ye Myo, we confiscated two mobile phones, 5 tickles of gold, and a plot
of land numbered (2207) at Bo Min Yaung Street, Ward No (71), South Dagon,
Yangon, from a trafficker who aided in rounding up girls, we confiscated a house
at Moe Hnan Kone Village, Pyaw Bwe Township which was bought from proceeds
accrued through human trafficking. All apprehended traffickers will be put on
trail in accordance with Anti-Trafficking in Persons Law.
I would further like to dwell on another case involving a
girl from Myeik who used to work for Garman cold storage factory starting from
April 2002. After she had worked there for over a year, the factory closed down
due to shortage of raw materials and at the invitation of her cousin aunt, she
went to Ranong in May 2004 to work in a furniture factory where she got married
to a rubber plantation worker named Nay Min Tun aged 22, son of U Tut from Ahnan
Village, Thanbyuzayet. She later learnt that her husband was having an affair
with the female owner of the plantation and when she confronted with her
husband, she was threatened by the owner. On the night of 15 October 2005, while
she was sleeping within the compound of the plantation, she felt burning
sensations on her face and later weak up to learn that she was splashed with
acid and had to be hospitalized for treatment at a nearby hospital.
After being treated in hospital six months, she went back
to her hometown in April 2006. However, the burns were so severe that she had to
undergo reconstructive surgery on 31 October 2006 at the Yangon General Hospital
Surgical Department for Facial, Jaw and Throat Surgeries with the assistance of
Myanmar Women's Affairs Federation and NGOs.
She had filed a case against her cousin aunt Daw Win that
has exploited her salaries in accordance with the Anti-Trafficking in Persons
Law section 24.
The assistance provided by Myanmar Women's Affairs
Federation and related NGOs during her repeated operations at Yangon General
Hospital coupled with the humanitarian assistance she is receiving; we learnt
that her physical conditions have improved. I would like to present that this is
a classic example of the role taken by Myanmar Women's Affairs Federation, a
local NGO, in caring for the trafficking victims.
In the same context, I would like to report on the actions
taken against the newly discovered gang that is sexually exploiting children in
Yangon. Since 2001/2002 we came to learn the existence of foreigners visiting to
Myanmar as tourists to exploit children and through the information imparted by
the Australian Federal Police, we caught one German national by the name of Mr
Rabler (aged 35) engaging in sexual abuse with two children at Ywama Hotel in
Hline township in December 2003 and took action against him.
Later in November 2006, we were able to interpret
information from two different sources?one from the Special Branch of Myanmar
Police Force and another from local police forces?to become aware of the
existence of brokerage gangs that are aiding foreigners who are visiting to
Myanmar as tourist to sexually abuse children here in Myanmar.
Based on this information, members of Yangon Division
police force, in cooperation with the special anti-human trafficking unit,
rounded up three prominent brokers on 13 November 2006. Linkages emanating from
interrogations led to the exposure of another 21 brokers from this ring within
nine days, including two who are currently serving sentences from crimes they
committed earlier.
Through these brokers, we learnt that 10 foreigner
paedophiles have sexually abused children here in Myanmar. Those are 3 from
Denmark, 2 each from US and Dutch, 1 Each from British, Austria and Canada.
One of the key players here is Myat Ko who lives in Dala
and I would like to explain how he was used as a broker. Born on 5 November
1987, Myat Ko is the eldest son with a younger sibling and since the age of 14
he started selling postcards around Sule and Botahtaung pagodas in 2003. He met
Dr Michael Pastoor, a German citizen who was visiting Myanmar as a tourist and
we learnt that he went to meet Myat Ko's parents and verbally promised to adopt
the boy. At the end of the year 2003, Myat Ko was sent to FMA school on Maha
Bandoola Street to learn English language and then was moved to IEC school on
Sula Pagoda Road where he attended the English school for the whole year of
2004. Between March, June and August 2005, he visited Chiang Mai and Ahyudaya in
Thailand together with Michael and later to Berlin, Germany. In November 2005,
Michael bought an apartment No Ma/67 (Ka) on Dhamayon Street, Sangyoung township
in the name of Myat Ko for a price of nineteen million kyats and then was sent
to Thailand for three months to learn Thai language. Michael, under the guise of
his adopted son, taught Myat Ko how to use Internet and to speak English and
now, although Myat Ko's education is only of fourth grade level, we learnt that,
in addition to his sound knowledge on the use of Internet, he can also speak
English, Thai and German. Using the Internet Cafe at Dagon Centre, Myat Ko
surfed the web for clients in foreign countries and from his website, we found
that he has connections in Germany, Italy and Thailand. It is evident that
Michael had used Myat Ko to gather and distribute information locally, searched
for markets and to act as the main contact point for clients who would like to
indulge in such acts. We learnt that Myat Ko, together with Kyaw (one of the
arrested brokers) from Dala formed a gang of around 20 brokers and cruised
Mahabandoola Garden areas to lure innocent children to engage in sexual acts
with foreigners and then sent them to hotels where pornographic movies were
shown to these children and then engage in unnatural sex acts on reciprocal
basis. Victims earn around 5,000 to 7,000 kyats per session with brokers getting
5,000 to 10,000 kyats for each boy they brought. I am clarifying this incidence
for people to understand how the members of anti-trafficking units have exposed
child sex abuse cases that have infiltrated Myanmar from neighbouring countries.
I would like to take this opportunity to explain on Child
Sex Tourism here. There are more than 800 million tourists visiting countries
around the world annually out of which 156 million visited countries in Asia
with more than 51 million to 10 ASEAN countries. Similarly, exploiting children
sexually is also increasing and it is estimated that at least a million children
are being abused annually. According to a study undertaken by ?End Child
Prostitution, Child Pornography and Child Sex Tourism (ECPAT)? INGO, this
industry thrives in Vietnam, Sri Lanka, Cambodia, Thailand, and in central
American countries including Costa Rica, Mexico, Brazil and the United States
and that people indulging in child sex acts are visiting countries around the
world as tourists. It was further stated in the study report that the majorities
of child abusers are Americans and include Germans, French, Swedish, Danish and
British people as well.
As the problem of exploiting children sexually is closely
linked to trafficking, we are giving special attention to this issue and since
1993; we have been taking measures to protect children in accordance with the
Convention on the Rights of the Child and the Myanmar Child Law. In June 2006 ,
40 members of Myanmar Police Force are being trained by ARCPPT project and
became members of Anti-Trafficking Unit formed then, Similarly, anti-trafficking
task forces were formed in nine border towns to undertake measures to protect
children and suppress human trafficking. Between the periods 2001 to 2006, we
have conducted 15 training sessions for 540 police officials who have been then
assigned to different States and Divisions to protect tourists as well as to
watch and observe their criminal behaviours. The problem of child exploitation
is also linked to tourist industry and we learnt that the Ministry of Hotel and
Tourism, in cooperation with Australian based Child Wise Tourism Organization,
have conducted 5 workshops to educate 280 of its staff members on this problem.
Similarly, the Ministry of Home Affairs that spearheads the Central Body for
Suppression of Trafficking in Persons, conducted 2 workshops in cooperation with
the British Criminal Investigation Department for 70 participants and another 6
workshops in cooperation with UNICEF to enhance their knowledge and capabilities
on suppressing trafficking for 408 participants.
Although Myan-mar has successfully undertaken measures to
combat human trafficking, as I have explained in length earlier, one powerful
Western country, in line with its supper-handed strategies is alleging our
country one sided without taking into consideration of our comprehensive efforts
to develop our country and to suppress human trafficking. It had graded Myanmar,
based on their prevailing internal standards and legal norms, at the lowest
level (TIER-3) in combating human trafficking for the past six years since the
2000.
Additionally, it has extended the sanctions imposed
unrealistically to deter our efforts in modernizing and developing Myanmar
economically.
We can fairly say that the emergence of human trafficking
problems in small countries emanated from the supper-handed actions of a
powerful country aimed at taking advantage of the smaller ones inequitably.
To cite an example, this particular powerful country, based
on unfounded allegations, imposed economic sanctions against Myanmar leading to
a closure of 160 garment factories within Yangon Division and the reduction of
workers from 40 such factories resulting in more than eighty thousand jobless
workers with problems for daily survival. This jobless work force include more
than seventy thousand female workers and by taking advantage of the problems
they are facing to sustain the daily livelihood of their families, some younger
ones were lured to become victims of this trafficking gambit. From these events,
we can fairly conclude that the fault lies upon a powerful country whose upper
handedness in interfering in the internal affairs of Myanmar resulted in this
state of affairs.
We would therefore like to refute the allegation that
Myanmar is amongst the weakest countries that had not conformed to the measures
prescribed in the lowest category of human trafficking grading of a powerful
Western country. The practical measures undertaken by Myanmar clearly testify
that Myanmar is one of the most effective countries that have effectively
suppressed human trafficking.
On one side, this powerful country, instead of showing good
will towards our efforts in suppressing human trafficking and lending
assistance, it is imposing sanctions based on unfounded allegations which are
directing young Myanmar girls to become victims of human trafficking trade. As
you all are aware, Myanmar Women's Affairs Federation (MWAF) that has tirelessly
assisted in measures to suppress human trafficking have unequivocally denounced
the grading of Myanmar at TIER-3 category in the June 2006 report on human
trafficking produced in June 2006 by a Department of that powerful country.
In conclusion, I would like to emphasize that, although the
neo-colonialist powerful country together with destructive elements have
launched multi faceted moves to deter and disrupt our honest endeavours, Myanmar
can never condone human trafficking and would continue to cooperate with our
neighbour and other humanitarian organizations, relying on our own social
environment and inter strength, in combating this threat.
![]()
Questions and answers made at the press conference on
undertakings in education, health and social affairs sectors of the State
Nay Pyi Taw, 30 Nov -he following are the questions and
answers made at the press conference on undertakings carried out in education,
health and social affairs sectors of the State held here at the Ministry of
Health yesterday.
U Myat Khaing (Snap Shot Journal): I would like to ask the
MPF Director-General about the problem of narcotics. I heard the country is
solving this problem in cooperation with the international community and
achieving success. Some places have been declared drug free zones. But our
country is still being criticized for the problem. Besides, narcotic drugs are
still being trafficked and arrests made in the country. Why is it so?
Another question is that according to the MPF DG, Kyaw
Myint sold about 90 women to contacts in China. Fatty (a) Ye Myo also sold 14
others to that country. In those cases, some of them were rescued. What I also
heard is that foreigners are using the children for sexual abuses. How long has
it happened so? Are there any other persons to be arrested?
MPF Director General: In connection with the smuggling of
narcotics in our country, already-processed drugs such as heroin, Ice and
methamphetamine tablets cannot be produced in our country alone. I have
mentioned about it repeatedly. I think to produce such kinds of drugs we need
precursor chemicals. Myanmar as a developing nation cannot produce precursor
chemicals. So, we cannot say that narcotic drugs are produced by our country
alone. Precursor chemicals can be smuggled into the country via the other
country. In this way narcotic drugs are there in our country. To solve this
problem the State has laid down a 15-year project from 1999 to 2014. ASEAN's
goal of setting up drug free region is in 2015. But our goal will be achieved in
2014, one year earlier than that of ASEAN.
There was accusa-tion against our country concerning the
problem of narcotics in the American-annually issued Periodical Determination
publication. No matter how we've been accused, we will continue our efforts to
make the country the drug free one by 2014. They are pointing the accusing
finger at us from their own point of view.
Regarding the problem of human trafficking, especially
child sex abuse, that problem emerged in the country in 2001. But the world had
seen the problem earlier. It is very common on the Internet. During the year of
2003, MPF Headquarters in collaboration with Australian Federal Police (AFP)
arrested a German on charges of child sex abuse. However, he was deported as he
was infected with HIV. Again, we were able to arrest Myat Ko's gang induding the
leader. The gang is made up of 21 brokers and 11 foreigners. We got the name
list of some of the foreigners. Action has been taken against the brokers. Human
trafficking, in other words, is exploitation. It also connects with sexual
exploitation and labour exploitation. Human smuggling and human trafficking are
different. Human smuggling means sending one illegally to another country by
charging money in violation of the existing law of that country. There is no
exploitation in this case. But there is exploitation in human trafficking. Now
those children are sexually exploited. So, this case is described as human
trafficking. According to the confession of the arrested brokers, there are more
persons to be arrested and interrogated. Trafficking in persons has links with
global tourism. It is mostly common in places like beach resorts and hotels.
Each year, some 50 million tourists come to Asia. Myanmar started to experience
this problem via the Internet used by some unscrupulous tourists making full use
of advancing information technology. This year, the dangerous person who
persuaded tourists coming to the country to abuse child is Mya Ko now under
arrest. He was brought up by a German and his education is only the forth
standard. He was sent to Thailand and Germany. He was trained to use the
Internet and speak English. He did his job on the Internet by offering the
illegal market of this country to the other country. He is expected to be 19
now.
U Yin Kyaw (Crime Journal) : The first thing I would like
to know is what is meant by human trafficking and human smuggling and how many
prison terms they can carry. It is said that, in Myanmar, human trafficking is
so rampant that it causes anxiety among the public and it has reached a critical
point. I would like to know what steps are being taken to control these crimes.
Nowadays, video houses are everywhere in villages and towns and cities. These
videos have bad effects on children and youths. As I am in charge of crime news,
I see that there are about seven or eight reports on sexual crimes in which
children and youths are involved. How should they be educated about sex? Which
departments are responsible for controlling these crimes? Is it only the duty of
Myanmar Police Force?
Brig-Gen Khin Yi : As I have already explained, the main
difference between human trafficking and human smuggling is exploitation. Human
trafficking is selling, buying and handing over people by persuation with the
intention of exploitation. In the case of human traffficking, the person who
traffics exploits the one who is trafficked. Here, the exploitation can be
either sexual exploitation or labour exploitation. The former does not give in
full what the latter deserves. In the case of smuggling, there is no
exploitation. For instance, a person wants to go abroad to work. At this, a
broker offers to send him by taking fees for his service. In such a case, there
is no exploitation but there is a breach of existing immigration act. I think
you will understand the difference between human trafficking and human
smuggling. Now I will explain how action is taken regarding human trafficking.
The human trafficking law was enacted in Myanmar on 13 September, 2005. Before
that, a person who committed human trafficking had to face a charge of
persuasion under Section 366 and the maximum penalty carries from five years in
prison or transportation. Since 13 September, 2005, human trafficking can carry
life imprisonment. At present, 44 offenders in 36 cases are being tried in
accord with the new law. One of them has been sentenced. According to the new
law, an offender can be given life imprisonment. In addition, his property and
asset can be confiscated if they are related with human trafficking. Regarding
the dimensions of human trafficking in Myanmar, it is not as dangerous as in
other countries. Most countries in the world, especially some neighbouring
countries, are vulnerable to this crime. There are also two or three vulnerable
countries in ASEAN. Most of the people who commit this crime are from the west.
They usually have same- sex relationship. Most foreigners who come here intend
to sexually abuse children and youths. At first, they committed such crimes in
other countries. Now they have come to our country with this ulterior motive. We
think that same sex crimes arose starting from 2001. The first time we exposed
such a crime was in 2003. According to our network, there are some brokers in
addition to the 21-broker gang we have exposed. And, in our country, human
trafficking is most in border areas and it is rare in inland areas. Therefore,
we can say that human trafficking has not yet become a national threat.
In connection with human trafficking, the government is
cooperating with related organizations especially ARCPPT in Asian region under
the four strategies. We handle the matter under the four-P strategy. The four Ps
are Prevention, Prosecution, Protection and Policy and International
Cooperation. Awareness system is being launched in the country. Related
ministries also conduct workshops on human trafficking. Over 500 MPF members
have been trained to handle the human trafficking. Task forces were deployed in
nine hot spot areas in the country. Awareness system includes the media and
distribution of pamphlets. Regarding the prosecution, we have taken action
against more than 1,600 people. Moreover, we are taking preventive measures.
Finally, we are cooperating with international community in accordance with the
policy and international cooperation strategy.The human trafficking is a kind of
transnational crime, it is the concern of all nations in the world. Therefore,
it cannot be handled by any individual country alone. Even in a country, it is
the concern of all the people, all NGOs and all UN agencies here. It can be
regarded as an international organized crime and must be tackled accordingly.
U Myo Thu (Hmukhin Shudaunk Journal): I'd like to ask
Director-General of Myanmar Police Force Brig-Gen Khin Yi whether ICRC would be
allowed to visit prisons or not in future because I heard that ICRC has not been
allowed to visit the prisons. There are accusations against the prison system of
Myanmar. So, I'd like to know how about the prison system of Myanmar.
Director-General of Myanmar Police Force Brig-Gen Khin Yi
It does not mean that we do not allow ICRC to visit the
prisons. Any organization or agency can perform their services in designated
regions in accordance with rules and regulations laid down by the Government. At
present, NGOs, such as Myanmar Women's Affairs Organization, Maternal and Child
Welfare Association and Union Solidarity and Development Association visit the
prisons and provided assistance to them. It does not mean that we marginalize
the ICRC and carry out its tasks. We are responsible for these tasks. ICRC and
other organizations would observe rules and regulations of our country. If they
fail to observe the rules and regulations, they may be prohibited from visits to
prisons.
NGOs in Myanmar have provided social assistance, provision
and medicines to prisoners. We did it on our own responsibilities. We don't need
to explain these activities if there are not false accusations against the
prison condition. We will also clarify the false accusation against the
Government in the media. News of the activities of the Prisons Department were
also put in the dailies.
U Kyaw Soe of Live News Journal: I would like to know
matters related to health sector. I heard a foreign radio had broadcast that
Japan will donate US$ 2.6 million to combating HIV/AIDS, malaria and other
diseases of Myanmar through UNICEF. Please tell me about it.
Minister for Health Dr Kyaw Myint: Japanese Government
hadn't provided such assistance for HIV/AIDS to Myanmar. However, UNICEF
officials and the Japanese Ambassador signed an agreement recently. Japan will
donate cash to the fund of UNICEF, and then UNICEF will manage the fund on
health matters of Myanmar.
Daw Aye Aye Win (AP News Agency): I would like to know the
reasons why the government has ordered to close down the five field offices of
ICRC.
Director-General of MPF Brig-Gen Khin Yi: Currently, there
are changes in focal point as to contacting the five field offices of ICRC in
the country. We are considering new rules and regulations for foreign
organizations. So, their functions are just temporarilly suspended.
Daw Aye Aye Win (AP News Agency): Is it so? But what I
learnt is that they were ordered to close down. Why? What I undestand is that
their operations were suspended because of the new regulation.
Director-General of MPF Brig-Gen Khin Yi: The new
regulation is under consideraton. We have not ordered them to close down. It is
just a short period of time in order to avoid complications to their obligations
before the new regulation is promulgated.
Daw Aye Aye Win (AP News Agency): Is it possible to reopen
their offices?
Director-General of MPF Brig-Gen Khin Yi: I will tell you
at oppurtune time.
Daw Aye Aye Win (AP News Agency): I would like to know the
government's opinion about the forced labour in Myanmar accused by ILO in
International Criminal Court.
Director-General of MPF Brig-Gen Khin Yi: General
Administration Deaprt-ment under the Ministry of Home Affairs plus the Ministry
of Labour are now trying to settle the matters of forced labour. We are tackling
this problem in accord with the rules and regulations and directives of our
country.
U Hein Latt of Popular Journal: Let me ask you about
trafficking in persons. I understand if anyone trafficks in women, children and
youths, the person will be sentenced to 10 years' or life imprisonment. I think
there will be some difference in imprisonment if somebody trafficks other
persons except women, youths and children. Please tell me the differences of
imprisonment.
MPF Director-General Brig-Gen Khin Yi: The imprisonment for
trafficking in women, children and youth is similar to that of other persons. In
reviewing facts and figures for three years, I counted equal number of men and
women under trafficking and sentence of imprisonment. The law concerning
trafficking in persons was promulgated on 13 September 2005. Before the law, the
vocabulary on trafficking in person was called human seduction. In this regard,
the person would be sentenced to imprisonment from 5 years' to life sentence.
Now, action will be taken against the offender to the life sentence under the
new law. Therefore, the person is to serve the whole life for the case until he
die. Gender will not be discriminated in the law.
U Zeya Myat Khaing (Gita Journal): I would like to ask you
three questions. The first is that an uncle and a nephew fell in a well and they
were killed in Pyinmana recently. You visited the scene. I want to know the case
because the well is only 13 inches wide. A fire broke out in Botahtaung Township
recently. Some reporters took photos of the fire and they were interrogated in
the township that night. I would like to know whether a reporter can take the
photo of outbreak of fire in Yangon or not. And can we take photos in Nay Pyi
Taw when we cover the news?
MPF Director-General Brig-Gen Khin Yi: Both uncle and his
nephew lost their lives when they fell in the well. I did visit the scene of
crime as it happened in Nay Pyi Taw. An inquest was made as there were no
injuries on their bodies. The police filed the case and investigated it.
According to the investigation, it is impossible to fall into the 13-inch wide
well. But a child can fall into the well. The man may fall into the well while
he was rescuing the child. According to the investigation by the doctor, there
were no injuries on the bodies caused by a thing. The two persons were killed
due to the lack of oxygen. The case is still under investigation.
Photo can be taken anywhere except restricted or security
areas. When we asked the reporter we could know where or when or from what angle
he shot. Action will be taken against those who are involved in outbreak of the
fire. There is no reason for the reporter to face action against him if he is
not guilty. Photo can be taken in Nay Pyi Taw if the area is not restricted.
Some areas of the armed forces cannot be shot.
U Zeya Myat Khaing (Gita Journal): I would like to ask the
Minister for Health. What kind of permission is given to the medical companies
regarding the import of HIV medicine?
Minister for Health Dr Kyaw Myint: Food and Drug
Administration is formed under the ministry. The FDA laid down policies in
connection with the import of new medicine and the imported medicines were
tested by Drug Administrative Committee (DAC). If the medicines are potent and
they have no side effects, the DAC recommends that the company can import the
medicine. The inspection team also inspects the imported medicine and price. If
everything is OK, I sign it and registration certificate is issued to the
company. Medicine importing team also decides that the price is reasonable or
not. Then I approve their recommendation.
U Aung Hla Tun (Reuters): I heard Min Ko Naing and four
were called in twice in custody of Section 5 J under the Emergency Provision
Act. Will action be taken against them? Has their case been put up to the court?
Or will the case be put up to the court?
MPF Director-General Brig-Gen Khin Yi: The Government is
questioning five ?88 generation students' including Min Ko Naing till today
about their participation in security and explosive matters. Indeed, they were
remanded in custody to prove that we do not keep anyone in custody illegally.
Decision will be made to take action against them depending on their
participation in security and explosive matters. If necessary, we will make
official clarification on their case.
U Aung Thu Myaing (Ji Ji News Agency): First, I would like
to ask you, Minister for Education. Please, tell me grading of Myanmar's
education standard at the international level. Is there corruption at the
ministry? If it is, will you have any arrangement to take action against
offenders?
Minister for Education Dr Chan Nyein: Matters related to
Myanmar's education standard was included in my report. Both basic and higher
education are being upgraded to meet the international standard. The task is
also included in the teaching course. The Head of State has given guidance with
regard to the education standard. Hence, teachers are being trained for
upgrading the basic education sector from the primary to the matriculation.
We are upgrading curricula and syllabus yearly, and
providing refresher courses for the teachers. Likewise, teachers at universities
are assigned duties to do researches in cooperation with international
institutions. Therefore, Myanmar is gaining progress of education standard day
by day. One day, we will achieve the aim of upgrading the education standard at
regional and international levels. With regard to corruption, teachers may
involve in the corruption cases concerning tuition and others. As far as I know,
the corruption is being combated clearly after I have taken responsibility of
Minister for Education. Now, the task of combating corruption continues.
However, there are about 250,000 education staff in the basic education and over
20,000 in the higher education. Action is being taken against those involved in
the corruption. At present, both teachers and students are abiding by respective
disciplines system atically.
U Ko Ko (Flower News Journal): I'd like to know the three
most common diseases in Myanmar and whether there was a plan for fighting these
diseases. I'd like to know if there was corruption in the Ministry of Health. If
so, how about a plan to fight the corruption?
Minister for Health Dr Kyaw Myint: Most are seasonal
diseases, for example, diarrhoea which breaks out during the rainy season.
However, Disease of National Concern are HIV/AIDS, Malaria and TB. There are
also diarrhoea and hypatitis.
Concerning the second question, there is a few cases of
corruptions in the ministry. Actions are taken against corrupt employees after
being investigated. The ministry also transfers and dismisses corrupt employees
if their cases are serious.
U Ko Ko (Flower News Journal): I'd like to know the three
most common crimes in Myanmar and if there were political prisoners in Myanmar.
How do you define a political prisoner? I'd like to know if there was corruption
in the Ministry of Home Affairs. If there was, how about a plan to fight the
corruption?
Director-General of Myanmar Police Force Brig-Gen Khin Yi:
According to the annual report, the first most common crime is the murder case
and those who were involved in murder cases are not premeditated ones. The
second is the theft case and the third is the cases of harm and injury. There is
no political prisoners in Myanmar. However, a person of a political party will
be jailed if he breaks the law. Therefore, prisoners are not designated as
political prisoners.
There are four institutions under the Ministry of Home
Affairs. They are Myanmar Police Force, Prisons Department, Bureau of Special
Investigation and General Administration Department. May be there are
corruptions in the departments. The ministry set up hot lines for the people to
inform the officials concerned of the ministry about the corruption and
malpractices in the ministry. In the letters sent to the ministry, most people
called for arresting the culprits.There is a few cases of corruption. If there
is a corruption case, we investigate the case and actions are taken against
corrupt employees.
U Ko Ko ( Flower News Journal): Rumours are abroad that the
basic education examinations will be held before earlier than usual in 2007
because of some important matter of the State. Is it true? Concerning the public
health care, patients are complaining about services and relations of private
hospitals and clinics. I would like to know how the Ministry of Health is trying
to handle the situation. Is there any law and action to be taken by the
ministry?
Education Minister Dr Chan Nyein: Rumour is a matter of
irritation for our country. Ministry of Education always announces every matter
officially. We have never made prompt announcements. We do everything giving
enough time in line with the rules and regulations.
Health Minister Dr Kyaw Myint: It is true that private
hospitals and clinics are overcharging for their services. We have known weak
points on health care and service charges. This is a good question. Laws on
private hospitals and clinics will be promulgated in the near future.
![]()
Officials reply queries raised by journalists
Nay Pyi Taw, 29 Nov-A press conference on undertakings in
education, health and social affairs sectors of the State was held at the
Ministry of Health, here, this morning and it was attended by President U Sao
Kai Hpa of Myanmar Foreign Correspondents Club, Secretary U Thitsar Hla Htway
and members, editors and journalists of local magazines and journals.
The journalists raised queries on clarification made by
Minister for Health Dr Kyaw Myint, Minister for Education Dr Chan Nyein, Deputy
Minister for Science and Technology U Kyaw Soe and Director-General Brig-Gen
Khin Yi of Myanmar Police Force and officials concerned made clarification.
(The clarifications are reported separately.)
Afterwards, diplomats, officials of UN agencies and
journalists viewed the five directives laid down by the Head of State in the
development of the education sector, educational vision and motto, extending of
educational opportunities, applying teaching aids, Education for All, promoting
skill of teachers, adult literacy, ten work programmes for 30-year long term
education promotion plan in the basic education sector, comparison of curricula
in high school level, newly opened universities and colleges, teaching
programmes, research departments and international forum, documentary photos and
facts and figures displayed at the press conference. They also observed work
done for welfare of prisoners in the sectors of religion, social affairs and
education, situation in prisons in the country, anti-human trafficking
endeavours, artifacts and products of prisons, documentary photos, anti-narcotic
drug drives of MPF, documentary photos of the Ministry of Science and Technology
and the Ministry of Health.
![]()
All citizens should always keep in the fore Our Three Main
National Causes, with political awareness
Yangon, 30 Nov -The following is the proposals of Lahu
National Development Party presented by U Kya Shi of the party on the detailed
basic principles that should be adopted for the chapters Election, Political
Parties and Provisions on State of Emergency to be included in drafting the
State Constitution at the Plenary Session of the National Convention held at
Pyidaungsu Hall of Nyaunghnapin Camp in Hmawby Township, Yangon Division, on
28-11-2006.
I wish you the esteemed Chairman and members of the Panel
of Chairmen, the Chairman of National Convention Convening Commission and
members, the Chairman of National Convention Convening Work Committee and
members, the Chairman of National Convention Convening Management Committee and
members and National Convention delegates to be blessed with health and
happiness and auspiciousness. I am U Kya Shi, a National Convention delegate of
Lahu National Development Party. I will now discuss the chapter Election
explained by the Chairman of National Convention Convening Work Committee.
Mr Chairman,
The Work Committee Chairman explained the detailed basic
principles for the chapter at the plenary session of the National Convention
held on 30 October 2006. They are in conformity with the stipulations stated in
the constitutions of world nations and 1947 Constitution and 1974 Constitution.
Hence, we find that the following points should be adopted as detailed basic
principles for the chapter.
Every citizen who has turned 18 on the date on which
elections commence, who is not disqualified by law, who is eligible to vote, and
who has the right to vote under the law, shall have the right to vote.
Every citizen who is eligible to vote and who has the right
to vote by the law shall cast only a vote for a Hluttaw each at a constituency.
In addition, people of national races concerned who are
eligible to vote in accordance with the provisions of the State Constitution
shall have the right to vote in electing representatives of national races to
the Region or State Hluttaw concerned.?
Ballot shall be exercised.
The following persons shall have no right to vote
(a) members of the Religious Order;
(b) persons serving prison terms;
(c) persons adjudged to be of unsound mind as provided for
in the relevant law;
(d) persons who have not yet been cleared from being
declared destitute; and
(e) persons who are banned from voting under the election
law.?
At an election, a candidate
(a) shall be elected to one Hluttaw only.
(b) shall stand for election at one constituency only.
(a) Electorate living in the Union territories, or the
Union territories designated by the Pyidaungsu Hluttaw under the law, shall
elect members of the Pyithu Hluttaw and the Amyotha Hluttaw only.
(b) Save as otherwise prescribed by the Constitution, a
Region or State Hluttaw member elected in a constituency that the Pyidaungsu
Hluttaw has designated as a Union territory shall no longer stand as a Hluttaw
member?
Every citizen who is not disqualified by the provisions of
this Constitution and the provisions of the law regulating elections shall have
the right to stand for election to a Hluttaw.
Mr Chairman,
The Work Committee Chairman presented in detail the matter
concerning the recall of an MP, citing the respective sections and articles of
the 1947 Constitution and 1974 Constitution as examples. Hence the para 6 and
subparas (a) to (e) should be adopted. The point,The Pyidaungsu Hluttaw shall
prescribe necessary laws on election and recall is also appropriate.
Now I will discuss the formation of the Pyidaungsu Election
Commission. The National Convention laid down a fundamental principle to enact
necessary laws for the formation of political parties for the flourishing of
genuine discipline-flourishing democracy. There should be a body to realize the
law concerning the parties. Hence the Pyidaungsu Election Commission should be
formed. Concerning the matter, the Work Committee Chairman made a thorough
explanation which includes 1947 Constitution and 1974 Constitution and the
constitutions of some nations. Hence, the paras 8 (a) and (b) and 9 (a) to (h)
should be adopted. The point ?If the President has to blame or charge the
chairman or a member of the Pyidaungsu Election Commission, he shall do so in
accord with the provision prescribed in this Constitution on blaming the Union
Chief Justice or any of Union Supreme Court Judges.? is comprehensive enough to
be adopted.
Mr Chairman,
The chairman and members of the commission should be
permitted to resign from it due to health grounds or other reasons. The points,
If the chairman or a member of the Pyidaungsu Election Commission in service
wishes to resign from his own accord due to his health condition or any of other
reasons, he may submit his resignation to the President. If the seat of the
chairman or a member of the Pyidaungsu Election Commission is vacant due to
resignation, termination of responsibilities, death, or any of other reasons,
the President may appoint a new chairman or a member of the Pyidaungsu Election
Commission in accord with the provisions on appointment of a Union minister
enumerated in the State Constitution. and If the chairman or a member of the
Pyidaungsu Election Commission is a government employee, he shall be deemed to
have resigned from civil service in accord with the existing civil service rules
and regulations from the date he is appointed as the chairman or a member of the
Pyidaungsu Election Commission. should be adopted as the detailed basic
principles.
Mr Chairman,
We would like to suggest that the following point should be
adopted:
The Pyidaungsu Election Commission's action and measures
over the following matters shall be final:
(a) electoral procedures;
(b) appeals and amendments on electoral benches' decisions
and orders;
(c) matters taken under political party law.
We also agree to the points Responsibilities, powers and
rights of the chairman and members of the Pyidaungsu Election Commission shall
be prescribed by law. and The role of the chairman of the Pyidaungsu Election
Commission is designated to be equivalent to the position of a Vice-President,
and a member, to the position of a Union minister in order to make reference to
responsibilities, powers and rights of the chairman and members of the
Pyidaungsu Election Commission in prescribing laws.
Disputes may arise in future if there is no explanation
about the stay of national people who went abroad for further study under the
permission of the government, on business or on personal affairs. Now, the
nation has launched the market-oriented economic system. Therefore, many
nationals are staying in foreign countries on duty with the permission of the
government, or on business, or on personal affairs. Such stay in foreign
countries should be deemed to have settled in the Union.
We would like to suggest that expression the period of
staying in foreign countries under State permission should be deemed to have
settled in the Union should be added to the point having settled in the Union of
Myanmar for at least 10 consecutive years up to the time of being elected as
Pyithu Hluttaw representative.
Mr Chairman,
I will now discuss the detailed basic principles for the
chapter Political Parties. The National Convention has already adopted the
fundamental principle the State shall enact necessary law for systematic
formation of political parties for flourishing of genuine multiparty democracy
system?. There should be a law to systematically establish political parties for
flourishing of discipline-flourishing genuine multiparty democracy system and
emergence of political parties that will correctly lead the citizens. The Union
of Myanmar that has been under the rule of her own monarchs became a colony
after three wars, the first one in 1824, the second in 1852, and the third in
1885, with the colonialists. The nation regained independence on 4 January 1948.
But she faced many dangers of insurgency resulting from colonialist instigation.
Hence, the Tatmadaw had to safeguard the nation. Every time
the Union faced disintegration, the Tatmadaw had to safeguard it. Time and
again, the Tatmadaw has safeguarded the nation. The neo-colonialists begrudging
the unity of the national races of the Union have been making attempts to break
up the national unity and the Union through various means to make Myanmar their
minion. All the citizens should always keep in the fore Our Three Main National
Causes, with political awareness. It is also necessary for political parties to
safeguard Our Three Main National Causes as a national duty.
Hence, the point Political parties set the objective
non-disintegration of the Union, non-disintegration of national
solidarity and perpetuation of sovereignty should be adopted as a detailed basic
principle.
Mr Chairman,
It is found that it is required to lay down detailed basic
principles concerning the qualifications of political parties as necessary,
after taking the experiences Myanmar had faced as lessons, for the flourishing
of genuine multiparty democracy in the nation. A political party must abide by
the Constitution and the existing laws in addition to accepting and exercising a
genuine multiparty democracy system. Moreover, it must be legally registered.
Hence, the following point should be adopted:
A political party shall:
(a) accept and practise discipline-flourishing genuine
multiparty democracy.
(b) abide by the Constitution and the existing laws.
(c) be legally registered as a political party.
A systematically formed political party can exist as a
political party and carry out organizational work in the nation in accord with
the law. In addition, it will have the permission to stand for elections held in
the nation.
We suggest that the following detailed basic principle
should be adopted:
In accordance with the law, a political party shall have
the right to:
(a) organize freely;
(b) to stand for elections.
In addition, the following point should be adopted as
detailed basic principle:
1. The continued existence of a political party shall not
be permitted if
(a) it has been declared as an unlawful association in
accord with the existing law.
(b) it contacts or abets the insurgent group waging the
armed rebellion against the State or the association or persons determined by
the State to have committed terrorist acts or the association declared to be
unlawful association directly or indirectly.
(c) it directly or indirectly receives financial, material
and other assistance from the government or a religious association, or any
other association or an individual person of a foreign country.
(d) it abuses religion for political purpose.
2. If the body having the authority to register political
parties finds that a political party is connected with anyone of the points
stated in the above-mentioned sub-paragraphs (a), (b), (c) or (d), the party's
registration shall be revoked.
Mr Chairman,
Political parties should be the organizations capable of
heading towards flourishing of discipline-flourishing genuine multiparty
democracy in the entire Union and in the respective Regions and States in accord
with the nation's political, security, economic and social conditions and
traditions and customs. It is opined that the Pyidaungsu Hluttaw should enact
necessary laws for the political parties to prevent differences when they carry
out the leadership role.
Hence the point The Pyidaungsu Hluttaw shall enact
necessary laws concerning the political parties. should be adopted.
Mr Chairman,
I will now present the chapter on the Provisions on State of Emergency. After studying the 1947 Constitution and the constitutions of some nations, it is found that the power to declare a state of emergency is vested in the President. But the power is not totally and independently vested in the President. The President has to submit the measures he has taken to the legislative bodies for approval. The study also shows that a state of emergency can be declared because of war, foreign invasion, armed insurgency, natural disasters, economic failures and the President's assumption that a grave situation is endangering the